Canada Kicks Ass
Private school success due to better students, not schools

REPLY

Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next



Tricks @ Wed Apr 01, 2015 6:01 pm

andyt andyt:

2.5 hours a day?

2.5 hours per class. 2 classes (or 3 for some) a day.

   



andyt @ Wed Apr 01, 2015 6:04 pm

Intensive. People usually lose focus if they go that long. I think 90 minutes was found to be optimum.

   



Jabberwalker @ Wed Apr 01, 2015 6:37 pm

Thanos Thanos:
2Cdo 2Cdo:
Thanos Thanos:
And with Wynnes latest stupid move about upping the airport fuel tax, thus creating expansion in small airports in the US states bordering Ontario, she's aiming to increase the job migration out of Ontario.


As a good social liberal who was instrumental in the debacle of the McSquinty years, Wynne's obligated by ideology to cause as much damage as she possibly can. At least it'll put that Dutch disease nonsense out to pasture because if high oil prices caused problems for Ontario she's certainly doing what she can to ensure that Ontario is going to benefit zilch from an extended period of low oil prices.


We're galloping into a recession right now so "hurting" oil is not beneficial to Ontario. Most of us never thought so in the first place.

   



martin14 @ Wed Apr 01, 2015 10:50 pm

Thanos Thanos:
introductory classes in the trades and concentrating far too much on the belief that everyone is capable of going onto a professional career via university. They all aren't, and it's incredibly destructive to operate the entire system under this assumption. To paraphrase Einstein, the best way to encourage a child to believe that he/she is an idiot is to force on them an education they're unsuited for instead of training them with one that will allow them to thrive. Why take a mechanical genius and ruin his life for him by telling him that becoming a mechanic, or welder, or carpenter


In Holland, long time ago, students used to take a barrage of aptitude tests at 14 or so.

If the kid took the path the tests showed, their education was subsidized.


Slovakia still has specialized secondary schools; trades, business, general education, university preparation.



$1:
How about concentrating more on what public schools are doing wrong, and working to logically fix it, instead of making private schools the bugbear for every problem that comes along? The wealthy are going to go to private schools period, even if they have to leave the country to do so. No amount of caterwauling is going to prevent that from happening.


Because that would require the public schools to do something, rather than sitting
on their fat asses, behind their fat public unions, and complaining.

This is much better for them.



Thanos Thanos:
Ontarion might as well go for broke and form their own country because they already have a public debt the same size, or greater, as that of most First World nation-states. :|



Yeah, Greece comes to mind. :lol:




fifeboy fifeboy:

By the way, have you ever tried to teach algebra to someone who does not know how to add, subtract, multiply or divide fractions. It's a real treat and I think it would be useful for all the critics of public education. Especially when the teacher is instructed that no one is to fail.


Just make sure you keep on pushing the idiots through the system, and chasing the
lowest possible denominator.

And then people wonder why private schools do better.

Or get angry about it. :lol:

   



OnTheIce @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 6:35 am

fifeboy fifeboy:
It's a funny thing. Everyone says they want "standards" until the teacher tells them that Johnny is not doing well and will fail if he doesn't pay attention, do his homework and cooperate in class. So, yes, if that is what happens (and it's my understanding it does) than it's the public's fault.


Not exactly fair to say that every parent faced with the same information would act as you described.

fifeboy fifeboy:
Also, check out the amount of public participation there is in "public education." How many people know what are the expectations spelled out in the curriculum of their Province. How many take education into consideration when voting (or even vote in the school board elections?) Democracy is supposed to be a hands on thing. Schools are supposed to be a hands on thing, but everyone appears to think that means interfering with the classroom teachers teaching of their kids, not with the Ministry of Ed. So, yep, ya gets what ya pay for(so to speak)


If schools are supposed to be a 'hands on' type of thing, why are teachers out of reach to questions and scrutiny of their work?

   



fifeboy @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:41 am

martin14 martin14:




fifeboy fifeboy:

By the way, have you ever tried to teach algebra to someone who does not know how to add, subtract, multiply or divide fractions. It's a real treat and I think it would be useful for all the critics of public education. Especially when the teacher is instructed that no one is to fail.


Just make sure you keep on pushing the idiots through the system, and chasing the
lowest possible denominator.

And then people wonder why private schools do better.

Or get angry about it. :lol:

I have never met a public school teacher who wanted to
$1:
Just make sure you keep on pushing the idiots through the system, and chasing the
lowest possible denominator.

They are told to pass people who shouldn't be passed. Why is that? I know teachers who had their marks changed on the report card, by the office, at the request of the school board. That must be because the teachers are
$1:
sitting
on their fat asses, behind their fat public unions, and complaining.

   



Jabberwalker @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:51 am

Yeah, Greece comes to mind. :lol:

We're not "Greece" yet or even Italy. Let's just say that Ontario is a f-cked up as France ... or even the U.K., for that matter.

   



fifeboy @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:53 am

OnTheIce OnTheIce:
fifeboy fifeboy:
It's a funny thing. Everyone says they want "standards" until the teacher tells them that Johnny is not doing well and will fail if he doesn't pay attention, do his homework and cooperate in class. So, yes, if that is what happens (and it's my understanding it does) than it's the public's fault.


Not exactly fair to say that every parent faced with the same information would act as you described.

fifeboy fifeboy:
Also, check out the amount of public participation there is in "public education." How many people know what are the expectations spelled out in the curriculum of their Province. How many take education into consideration when voting (or even vote in the school board elections?) Democracy is supposed to be a hands on thing. Schools are supposed to be a hands on thing, but everyone appears to think that means interfering with the classroom teachers teaching of their kids, not with the Ministry of Ed. So, yep, ya gets what ya pay for(so to speak)


If schools are supposed to be a 'hands on' type of thing, why are teachers out of reach to questions and scrutiny of their work?

And you are very right here. It's only a few parents who do such things, but they are the ones who will head straight to the Principals office after an interview to complain and then call the director of education to try to get the teacher who is "holding back poor little Johnny" fired. Ask a teacher. I bet most have had that experience.
Most parents do want to work with the school and improve their child's learning experience, but a few ...

In regards to your second question: Are they? You are telling me that you as a parent can't say anything. You must have been in some school I have never been in. Calls and imput from parents are appreciated things, they were in my school and they are in the school my kid goes to now. I am usually able to get same day access to both Principal and teacher (except band and English teacher, who move around from school to school and may not be available this day, but will be within 2 days.)

   



Tricks @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:58 am

andyt andyt:
Intensive. People usually lose focus if they go that long. I think 90 minutes was found to be optimum.

We had a break half way through.

   



Benn @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 9:42 am

andyt andyt:
ShepherdsDog ShepherdsDog:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/private-school-success-due-to-better-students-not-better-schools-statscan-1.3016123

Motivation is everything, and that is something that can't be taught or instilled, despite what some nimrods running the system think. It has to come from within.


Sure sure, because this:
$1:
"Two factors consistently account for these differences," the report released on Tuesday said. "Students who attended private high schools were more likely to have socio-economic characteristics positively associated with academic success and to have school peers with university-educated parents."
has nothing to do with it. Ie not some intrinsic trait (genetic superiority of private school students?) but external factors like the fact your parents are able to support you academically and enrich your learning opportunities and you're in a class with people from the same background instead of having all sorts of special needs students in your class taking the teacher's attention.

No, no, it's some inborn trait of the elite. As for success in later life, the connections the parents have has nothing to do with that either.


Think this is the second time in a month I've had to give a nod to Andy, maybe its something in the water lately.

Either way I think he is right with what he says in the bolded part of his quote. Our kids are in semi-private school and for my wife's own first six years she took German Immersion in a public school (then went private from 7 - 12) She noticed not only her class but all the German immersion classes on average had better grades than the regular students and always speculated this had to do with the type of parents who enrolled their kids in those programs. Ones likely more interested in their kids education and providing the most benefits to them in their educations (learning another language does more than just lets you speak in another language). What I observe in our private school are parents who are more involved and on average more educated than public school parents. Many have also been the product of a public system failure or their kids have been subjected to problems with the public system. So in general while I think the caliber of the education is slightly better it is also the importance put on it at home is different and therefore drives the kids a bit more. This is by no means saying great involved parents are not in the public system, simply the ratio is higher in private. It is certainly a big financial burden at our income level but we feel its worth it and we may put them in public school from middle school onwards once they have a good grounding to work from.

The part of being in a class with those with similar backgrounds and no special needs however is, at least in my kids school, not true. There are certainly other backgrounds and cultures as well as special needs in our school and resources dedicated to them, my daughter is one of them.

BTW to those who poo poo on private school families don't forget we still pay school taxes like the rest of you but in our case we provide ZERO draw on the public system, so we're giving the public system free money for no return, our taxes just benefit your kids, not ours. So in a way we're helping the public system more than public school families are.

   



andyt @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 9:48 am

Thank you, but actually I was just referring to the op. Why that would cause Shep to fling shit and his circle jerkers to join in is beyond me.

In BC, private schools are funded at 50% of public schools, so zero draw doesn't apply here. The only problem with private schools, like a private healthcare system, is that the govt starves the public one. If it didn't do that, there would be zero complaints about the private system.

   



martin14 @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 10:33 am

Jabberwalker Jabberwalker:
Yeah, Greece comes to mind. :lol:

We're not "Greece" yet or even Italy. Let's just say that Ontario is a f-cked up as France ... or even the U.K., for that matter.



Just wait til interest rates go up, should be about the time she gets her real spending
purse out.

Get out while you can. :P

   



Regina @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 11:04 am

BartSimpson BartSimpson:

Then why the angst over the private schools if the public schools are almost as good?


We have no angst at all about private schools. And by your description our school system doesn't resemble yours in the least. Shep can comment on this more accurately but it is not up to the provincial government to deliver education. The curriculum is set by the province but it is the local school boards that decide how the city's education tax is spend and where. About the only gripe I hear about schooling is why we are funding Catholic schools since they are religion based. Even blaming the provincial government is a bit of a stretch here.

   



ShepherdsDog @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 12:04 pm

$1:
Why that would cause Shep to fling shit

Mainly because that's all you're deserving of. You aren't worthy of serious dialogue.

   



2Cdo @ Thu Apr 02, 2015 12:12 pm

ShepherdsDog ShepherdsDog:
$1:
Why that would cause Shep to fling shit

Mainly because that's all you're deserving of. You aren't worthy of serious dialogue.


Bingo. [B-o]

   



REPLY

Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next